Detroit took five penalties in a 10-minute stretch of the second period on Nov. 7, by coach Todd McLellan’s count to NHL.com, and the Avalanche made them pay. Martin Necas knocked in a loose puck during a goal-mouth scramble at 9:46. Nathan MacKinnon scored on another power play less than three minutes later, and Cale Makar added a third power-play goal in the third period of a 4-0 win at Ball Arena.
The question is whether that night was a spike or the shape of things. Through Nov. 12, the numbers say the power play really is better than it was in October, though not as good as its opening night suggested.
Four on opening night, then almost nothing
The season started with a mirage. Colorado went 4-for-5 against Los Angeles on Sept. 30, with the second unit scoring three of the goals, according to Colorado Hockey Now and On SI.
Then it went cold. The Avalanche were 0-for-13 in the next four games, the Denver Gazette reported after an 0-for-5 night in a 6-3 home loss to Toronto on Oct. 10. From the second game through the 10th, Colorado went 2-for-27, according to Hockey-Reference’s game log.
That left the Avalanche at 6-for-32 through 10 games, an 18.8% conversion rate. Last season’s unit had finished near the bottom of the league, the Gazette’s Evan Rawal wrote in his season preview, and the first month looked like more of the same.
A new voice on Oct. 16
The coaching change came eight games in. Dave Hakstol, who ran the power play, left to become head coach at Arizona State, and assistant Brett McLean took over the unit for the Oct. 16 game against Pittsburgh, according to the AP and Colorado Hockey Now. MacKinnon scored a power-play goal in the third period of that 5-2 win, the AP reported.
Colorado Hockey Now reported that coach Jared Bednar gave McLean room to change whatever he wanted and that the staff held long power-play meetings with him before his first game. The personnel didn’t change much. The top unit going into Thursday’s game at Ottawa was MacKinnon, Makar, Necas, Nazem Kadri and T.J. Hughes, according to Inside The Rink’s pregame lines, the same five Colorado Hockey Now reported after an Oct. 6 practice.
The results did. Over the last 10 games, Colorado is 10-for-35, a 28.6% rate, according to Colorado Hockey Now and Hockey-Reference’s game log. Colorado Hockey Now ranked that eighth in the league over the span.
The full-season line has climbed with it. Colorado is 16-for-67, a 23.9% rate that ranks 11th in the NHL through Nov. 12, according to the NHL’s team statistics.
The goals are spread out. MacKinnon, Necas, Artturi Lehkonen and Kadri have three power-play goals apiece, Gabriel Landeskog has two, and Makar and Brock Nelson have one each, according to Hockey-Reference.
The penalty kill, and the injuries
The other half of special teams has steadied, too. Nashville scored four power-play goals on seven chances in a 6-2 win over Colorado on Oct. 25, according to NHL.com and Hockey-Reference. In the eight games since, the Avalanche have allowed three power-play goals on 25 chances, according to Hockey-Reference’s game log. They killed all five of Ottawa’s power plays Thursday.
Colorado’s penalty kill is 49-for-61, an 80.3% rate that ranks 10th in the league through Nov. 12, according to the NHL’s team statistics.
Now the improvement faces its first real test. MacKinnon and Makar both left Thursday’s 4-3 overtime loss at Ottawa in the second period with lower-body injuries, and Bednar said after the game he wasn’t sure whether either would play Saturday, according to the AP and the Denver Gazette. Both traveled with the team to Montreal, Colorado Hockey Now and USA Today reported.
There’s a small piece of evidence on what happens without them. Both of Colorado’s power-play goals at Ottawa came after the two stars had left, according to the Gazette and NHL.com’s goal times. Lehkonen scored late in the second period with what the Gazette called a makeshift top unit, and Landeskog scored with the second unit in the third.
One game is a small sample, and the second unit has scored since opening night. But MacKinnon and Makar scored two of the three power-play goals against Detroit, and both are fixtures on the top unit.
The Avalanche play at Montreal at 5 p.m. Mountain time Saturday, Nov. 14, with no announced status for MacKinnon or Makar.





